The written version

The Utility of the Hartman Values Profile in Clinical Psychology Practice

I. Introduction

The role of values in shaping psychological well-being and influencing the therapeutic process has garnered increasing recognition within the field of clinical psychology. Understanding an individual's core values can provide crucial insights into their motivations, behaviors, and the underlying causes of their psychological distress. The Hartman Values Profile (HVP) stands as a unique assessment tool, rooted in the science of value known as Formal Axiology, developed by Dr. Robert S. Hartman.1 Dr. Hartman's groundbreaking work in this area led to his nomination for the Nobel Prize in 1973.4 This report aims to explore the theoretical framework underpinning the HVP, the dimensions it measures, its diverse applications within a clinical psychology practice, the empirical evidence supporting its use, its inherent limitations, its position relative to other assessment tools, and illustrative examples of its integration into clinical work. The objective is to provide a comprehensive understanding of how the HVP can serve as a valuable asset for clinical psychologists seeking to enhance their practice.

II. Understanding the Hartman Values Profile: Theoretical Framework

Formal Axiology: The Science of Value:
The Hartman Values Profile is built upon the foundation of Formal Axiology, a discipline developed by Dr. Robert S. Hartman that employs the principles of logic and mathematics to offer a structured understanding of the processes by which individuals formulate value judgments.1 Hartman posited that the act of valuing is not purely subjective but follows discernible logical structures that can be represented mathematically. His endeavor was to establish a "science of value" (axiology) capable of elucidating how individuals determine what they consider good or valuable. Formal axiology specifically concentrates on the inherent structure of the valuing process, rather than the specific content or objects of value. A central tenet of this theory is the principle that "a thing is good insofar as it exemplifies its concept".3 This suggests that the perceived value of an entity is directly proportional to the degree to which it fulfills its defining characteristics or ideal standard. For instance, a "good chair" would fully embody the essential attributes associated with the concept of a chair, such as having legs, a seat, and a back. Hartman's overarching goal was to introduce scientific rigor into the study of human values, thereby transcending the limitations of purely subjective or culturally relative interpretations.10 The HVP represents a practical application of this theoretical framework, designed to provide objective insights into an individual's distinct patterns of valuing. The mathematical basis of Formal Axiology offers a level of analytical precision that may be attractive to clinicians seeking assessment tools grounded in scientific principles.1 Furthermore, Hartman's emphasis on "concept fulfillment" as the fundamental basis of value provides a unique perspective for understanding psychological distress. Individuals might experience inner turmoil when their self-perception or their understanding of the world around them fails to align with their internal benchmarks or definitions of what constitutes "good" or valuable. In this context, the HVP could serve as a tool to identify these specific areas of misalignment.3
The Three Dimensions of Value:
At the core of Hartman's Formal Axiology are three fundamental dimensions through which individuals assign value: Intrinsic, Extrinsic (Practical), and Systemic (Conceptual).1

Intrinsic Value: This dimension pertains to valuing primarily individuals including oneself, for their inherent uniqueness and worth, viewing them as ends in themselves.1 It reflects the capacity to recognize and appreciate the distinct individuality of oneself and others, irrespective of any roles or functions they might fulfill. It is about valuing someone simply for their inherent being. This dimension is closely associated with empathy, the ability to understand and share the feelings of another, and self-esteem, a sense of personal worth and self-acceptance.12
Extrinsic Value (Practical): This dimension involves valuing things such as tasks, objects, and actions based on their utility, functionality, or as a means to achieve a particular end.1 It focuses on the tangible, practical aspects of the world and the ability to effectively utilize resources and take concrete actions to accomplish goals. It is fundamentally about "doing" and the tangible outcomes of those actions. This dimension encompasses practical judgment, which involves common sense and the ability to make sound decisions in everyday situations, and role awareness, which refers to an individual's understanding and valuation of their responsibilities and their place within the broader context of the world.12
Systemic Value (Conceptual): This dimension relates to the valuation of abstract concepts, ideas, systems, and order based on their contribution to a larger framework, their inherent meaning, or how they align with established norms or ideals.1 It involves the ability to discern patterns, logic, and structure within the world. This includes conceptual thinking, the capacity for planning, and adherence to established rules and standards. It is about comprehending the "big picture" and understanding the interconnectedness of various elements. This dimension incorporates systems judgment, the ability to analyze and understand complex systems, and self-direction, which pertains to internal standards, personal goals, and the intrinsic drive for self-improvement.12

These three dimensions are not mutually exclusive but rather represent distinct lenses through which an individual can value the world and their place within it.12 An individual might, for instance, value their profession from an intrinsic standpoint by finding personal fulfillment, from an extrinsic standpoint by earning a livelihood, and from a systemic standpoint by contributing to the overall mission of their organization. The three-dimensional model of valuing provides a robust framework for understanding the multifaceted nature of a client's value system.12 Furthermore, the associated sub-dimensions offer more detailed insights into specific tendencies within each of these broader categories.12

The Measurement of Value Judgments:
The Hartman Values Profile goes beyond simply identifying what an individual values; it assesses the clarity and focus with which they make value judgments across these three fundamental dimensions.17 The profile evaluates not only the content of an individual's values but also the quality of their judgment within each dimension, including their ability to differentiate values and the consistency with which they apply their valuing patterns. Key concepts in this measurement include "Clarity," which refers to the sharpness of perception within each value dimension, and "Attention/Bias," which indicates the degree of focus and importance an individual naturally assigns to each dimension when making decisions.17 High clarity signifies that a person can easily discern nuances and make accurate judgments within a specific dimension, while "Attention/Bias" reveals the natural emphasis or weight they give to that dimension in their decision-making processes. Critically, the HVP identifies both an individual's strengths, representing areas of high clarity and balanced attention leading to effective judgment, and potential "blind spots" or biases, which occur when there is a lack of clarity or an overemphasis or underemphasis on a particular dimension, potentially resulting in skewed perceptions and less effective decisions.12 The HVP's sophisticated analysis of the valuing process provides a deeper level of understanding that can be more informative for clinical intervention than simply knowing what a client states they value.19 The identification of these blind spots can be particularly beneficial in therapy, as it can help clients become aware of unconscious biases that may be contributing to their presenting problems.20

III. The Value of Value Hierarchy in Clinical Insight

The Hartman Values Profile is instrumental in identifying an individual's unique hierarchy of values.12 By assessing the relative strength and clarity of valuing across the three dimensions and their associated sub-dimensions, the HVP generates a personalized profile that illustrates which values are most dominant and exert the greatest influence in an individual's life. This hierarchical structure offers valuable insights into several key aspects of a client's psychological landscape. Understanding a client's value priorities can illuminate the underlying driving forces behind their behaviors and the choices they make.10 For instance, if a client places a high value on intrinsic aspects like interpersonal relationships, yet their life circumstances are heavily focused on extrinsic achievements, this fundamental mismatch can be a significant source of internal conflict. The HVP can effectively highlight such discrepancies. Furthermore, the way in which a client weighs different values significantly influences their decision-making processes and their reactions to various situations.12 A client with a pronounced systemic value orientation, for example, might find themselves struggling with decisions that demand immediate action and lack detailed planning, as their natural inclination is towards conceptual understanding and a consideration of long-term implications. The HVP can effectively reveal this particular tendency. Perhaps most importantly for clinical practice, a misalignment between a client's core values and their lived experiences, their interpersonal relationships, or even their internal psychological state can be a significant precursor to psychological distress.2 The HVP can be instrumental in pinpointing specific value conflicts that may lie at the root of a client's presenting psychological problems. For example, a client who deeply values their sense of self (intrinsic value) but consistently finds themselves in roles that demand strict adherence to external rules and expectations (systemic value) might experience heightened anxiety or feelings of inauthenticity. The HVP's ability to map this value hierarchy provides a powerful tool for understanding the fundamental structure of a client's psychological world, allowing clinicians to discern which values hold the most sway and how they might interact with and influence other values and behaviors, thereby offering a more nuanced and comprehensive understanding than a simple list of stated values. Identifying inconsistencies or misalignments within this value hierarchy can be key to understanding the origins of a client's internal conflicts and the distress they experience.2

IV. Applications of the Hartman Values Profile in Clinical Practice

(a) Identifying Core Values That May Be Misaligned or Unmet, Contributing to Psychological Issues:
The Hartman Values Profile can be a valuable tool in revealing discrepancies between the values that a client consciously espouses and the values that are actually driving their behaviors.5 Clients may articulate certain values as being important to them, but their HVP results might indicate a different set of priorities are evident in their actual patterns of decision-making and judgment. This incongruence can be a significant source of internal conflict and psychological distress. Furthermore, when an individual's fundamental core values, such as the need for meaningful connection, a sense of autonomy, or a feeling of purpose, are consistently unmet in their life, it can significantly contribute to the development of anxiety, depression, and a range of other psychological problems.17 The HVP can help to identify these potential blocks to an individual's overall well-being by providing insights into their underlying value system.17 This objective data can then support clinical observations regarding value conflicts and their impact on a client's mental health, moving beyond potentially subjective client reports.20 For instance, a client presenting with persistent feelings of emptiness might score low on intrinsic valuing of self and others, indicating a potential unmet need for self-acceptance and meaningful interpersonal connections. By identifying these misalignments, the HVP can assist the therapist and client in focusing their therapeutic efforts on addressing the fundamental causes of the client's distress, rather than solely focusing on the alleviation of symptoms. For a client experiencing significant anxiety, the HVP might reveal an overemphasis on the need for systemic control coupled with a lack of intrinsic self-acceptance, suggesting a clear direction for therapeutic intervention that addresses both of these underlying value dynamics.
(b) Facilitating Self-Awareness and Personal Growth by Helping Clients Understand Their Own Value System:
The Hartman Values Profile report provides clients with a wealth of information regarding their inherent strengths, potential biases in their thinking, and their unique ways of perceiving both the external world and their own internal landscape.19 The report typically outlines an individual's scores in terms of clarity and attention across the three primary value dimensions and their associated sub-dimensions, effectively highlighting their natural strengths in the realm of valuing and also pointing out potential areas of bias or oversight in their judgment processes. This enhanced level of self-awareness can be incredibly empowering for clients, enabling them to make more conscious and deliberate choices in their lives that are more closely aligned with their deeply held core values, thereby fostering a greater sense of personal growth and authenticity.6 When clients gain a clearer understanding of their own value system, they are better equipped to identify what truly holds significance for them and to make choices in their relationships, their careers, and their personal lives that are more congruent with these fundamental values, ultimately leading to an enhanced sense of purpose and overall fulfillment.20 The HVP acts as a powerful catalyst for self-reflection and a more profound understanding of one's internal compass.27 Many clients entering therapy struggle with a lack of clarity regarding their own sense of self and what truly matters to them. The HVP offers a structured and relatively objective framework through which they can explore their values and gain insight into how these values shape their perceptions and influence their behaviors.31 Furthermore, the HVP's focus on identifying both strengths and potential biases in an individual's valuing patterns provides a balanced perspective for clients, fostering a greater sense of self-acceptance while also highlighting specific areas where there is potential for further personal development.20 By understanding their natural tendencies, both positive and potentially limiting, clients can learn to leverage their strengths more effectively in their lives and to consciously work on mitigating the negative impact of their inherent biases.
(c) Improving Therapeutic Rapport by Understanding the Client's Perspective Through Their Values:
The Hartman Values Profile can significantly enhance the therapeutic relationship by providing the therapist with a deeper understanding of the client's unique way of valuing the world, thereby fostering greater empathy and a more profound connection.12 By gaining insight into the client's specific value hierarchy, as well as their clarity and attention within each of the value dimensions, the therapist can begin to understand how the client perceives and interprets their life experiences.19 This understanding is crucial for cultivating empathy, as it allows the therapist to see the world through the client's individual lens. This deeper level of understanding, in turn, leads to more effective communication and a stronger therapeutic alliance between the therapist and the client.34 When the therapist has a clearer sense of what truly holds importance for the client, they can tailor their communication style and their overall therapeutic approach to be more resonant and meaningful for that individual, thereby strengthening the therapeutic bond and fostering a greater sense of trust and collaboration. The HVP can provide a valuable shortcut to understanding a client's core perspective, potentially accelerating the development of empathy and rapport in the early stages of therapy.31 Building a strong therapeutic alliance is fundamental to successful therapy, and the insights gained from the HVP can allow the therapist to connect with the client on a deeper level more quickly than might otherwise be possible. Furthermore, by understanding the client's specific valuing style, the therapist can consciously avoid making assumptions based on their own personal values and can instead tailor their interventions to be more closely aligned with the client's unique worldview.27 For example, if a therapist highly values emotional expression (intrinsic value) but their client prioritizes logical reasoning and factual analysis (systemic value), understanding this fundamental difference through the lens of the HVP can help the therapist communicate in a manner that resonates more effectively with the client's dominant valuing style.
(d) Informing Treatment Planning by Tailoring Interventions to Align with the Client's Values:
The insights derived from the Hartman Values Profile can be invaluable in informing the development of treatment plans that are specifically tailored to align with a client's core values, thereby significantly increasing their motivation and adherence to the therapeutic process.10 When the goals of therapy and the interventions employed are congruent with what a client truly values in their life, they are far more likely to be actively invested in the therapeutic process and to diligently work towards achieving those identified goals. For instance, if a client deeply values close interpersonal relationships (intrinsic value), therapeutic interventions might focus on enhancing their social skills or addressing any relational patterns that are hindering their ability to form and maintain meaningful connections. Conversely, a client who highly values achievement and competence in their work (extrinsic value) might benefit from interventions that focus on improving their performance or addressing any underlying issues that are impacting their professional success. Value alignment can be effectively incorporated into a variety of therapeutic approaches. In Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT), for example, the identification and subsequent action in accordance with one's core values is a central tenet of the therapeutic process. The HVP can be a powerful tool in helping clients to clarify their fundamental values, providing a solid foundation for values-based action planning. Similarly, in various values clarification exercises commonly used in therapy, the HVP can provide a structured and insightful framework for a deeper exploration of what truly matters to the client.10 Treatment plans that are driven by a client's core values are inherently more likely to be effective because they tap into the client's intrinsic motivation and their overarching sense of purpose.35 The HVP can also assist the therapist in identifying which specific types of interventions are likely to be most appealing and ultimately most effective for a particular client, based on their unique valuing style. For example, a client with a strong systemic orientation might respond particularly well to structured, logical, and evidence-based approaches to therapy, while a client who scores high in intrinsic valuing might benefit more from emotionally focused or humanistic therapeutic modalities.10
(e) Assisting in Career Counseling and Vocational Guidance by Identifying Values Relevant to Work Satisfaction:
While not the primary focus of this report, the Hartman Values Profile can also provide valuable insights in the realm of career counseling and vocational guidance by identifying the specific values that are most relevant to an individual's satisfaction in their work.6 The HVP measures how individuals value tasks, systems, and interpersonal interactions, all of which are fundamental aspects of the workplace. Understanding a client's priorities in these areas can be incredibly helpful in guiding them towards careers that are more likely to be fulfilling and aligned with their core values. For instance, an individual who highly values practical accomplishment (extrinsic value) might find satisfaction in a career that involves tangible results and hands-on work, while someone who prioritizes systemic order and conceptual understanding (systemic value) might be drawn to roles that involve planning, analysis, or research. Although career counseling might be considered a secondary application within a general clinical psychology practice, it is nonetheless a relevant area, as many clients present with issues related to work-related stress, job dissatisfaction, or the need to navigate career transitions. In these instances, the insights provided by the HVP regarding their work-related values can be particularly beneficial.6 For example, a client experiencing burnout in their current profession might discover through the HVP that their job does not align with their core values of autonomy or a sense of meaningful contribution. Integrating the HVP into career counseling services within a clinical practice can offer a more holistic approach to supporting a client's overall well-being, recognizing the significant impact that work life has on mental health. By helping clients identify and pursue more fulfilling career paths, clinicians can directly address a significant source of stress and dissatisfaction in their lives.
(f) Understanding Relationship Dynamics by Exploring Value Congruence and Differences Between Individuals:
Administering the Hartman Values Profile to individuals involved in close relationships, such as couples or family members, can be a powerful way to reveal underlying areas of value alignment as well as potential sources of value conflict, providing valuable insights for therapeutic intervention.13 By comparing the HVP profiles of the individuals within a relationship, a therapist can effectively identify the specific areas where their core values are either similar and mutually reinforcing or divergent and potentially leading to friction. These insights can be particularly helpful in explaining established patterns of communication, recurring conflicts, and the overall dynamics of connection within the relationship.39 For instance, in a romantic relationship, one partner might prioritize intrinsic values such as emotional intimacy and shared experiences, while the other partner might place a higher value on extrinsic factors like professional achievement and material success. Understanding these fundamental differences in their value hierarchies can shed light on many of the misunderstandings and conflicts they experience. This deeper understanding of the underlying value dynamics can then be used to facilitate more effective communication and to guide the process of conflict resolution within the therapeutic setting.13 When individuals in a relationship gain a clearer understanding of the core value differences that contribute to their conflicts, they can approach communication and problem-solving with a greater sense of empathy and a heightened willingness to find mutually acceptable compromises. The HVP offers a structured and relatively objective method for assessing value congruence and differences within relationships, moving beyond potentially subjective accounts of conflict provided by the individuals involved.13 Using the HVP in relationship therapy can also provide a common language and a shared framework for discussing often sensitive issues related to individual values and priorities, thereby facilitating more productive and constructive conversations between the involved parties. Instead of simply arguing about specific behaviors or events, partners or family members can utilize the insights from their HVP profiles to understand the underlying values that are driving those behaviors, ultimately leading to greater mutual understanding and empathy.

V. Research Evidence: Validity, Reliability, and Effectiveness

Validity:
The Hartman Values Profile has been the subject of research aimed at establishing its validity, or the extent to which it measures what it purports to measure.1 Studies on construct validity examine whether the HVP scores correlate with other measures of theoretically related constructs and if its internal structure aligns with Hartman's theory of axiology.1 Research on concurrent validity demonstrates the extent to which HVP scores correlate with scores on other established assessments that measure similar constructs, such as other value inventories or measures of related psychological traits.13 For example, studies have shown correlations between the HVP and the Allport-Vernon-Lindzey Study of Values and the Rokeach Value Survey.13 Furthermore, cross-validation studies have found concurrent validity with tools like the MMPI and Cattell CAQ.24 Criterion validity is established when the HVP scores can predict real-world outcomes that are theoretically related to the constructs it measures.1 Research has demonstrated the HVP's validity in predicting customer service and management characteristics.13 Notably, its successful use in predicting performance in demanding fields like surgical residency programs at the University of South Florida provides strong evidence for its criterion validity in high-stakes environments, which holds relevance for its potential application in understanding factors related to success and well-being in various clinical contexts.28 Follow-up studies with corporations like Sara Lee and James River Corporation also indicated that the HVP predicted exemplary performance in managerial success and customer service, respectively.40
Reliability:
Reliability, the consistency and stability of the assessment scores, has also been investigated for the Hartman Values Profile.5 Test-retest reliability, which refers to the consistency of scores when the same individuals take the HVP on two or more separate occasions, has been demonstrated over varying time intervals. For instance, the Hartman-Kinsel Profile, a related instrument, has shown reliability and stability over periods of months and even years.13 This temporal stability suggests that the HVP provides a relatively consistent measure of an individual's underlying value system. The reliability of the HVP supports its potential use as a tool for tracking changes in a client's value system over the course of therapy. Consistent scores over time indicate that observed changes are more likely to reflect genuine shifts in the client's internal landscape rather than inconsistencies in the instrument itself.37
Effectiveness:
Research suggests the effectiveness of the HVP in improving understanding, decision-making, and performance in various applied settings, including those relevant to clinical psychology.11 Its utility in enhancing resident selection processes in healthcare, leading to improved performance and reduced attrition rates, highlights its potential in understanding factors related to success in demanding and stressful environments.28 Moreover, the HVP has been reported to be used in clinical settings with psychotherapy clients, suggesting that clinicians find it to be a valuable tool for gaining insights into their clients' values and judgment patterns.24 The positive outcomes reported in organizational settings, such as improved hiring decisions, enhanced team dynamics, and better leadership development, further support the idea that the HVP can contribute to positive outcomes in clinical practice as well.11
Table 1: Summary of Key Research Studies on the Hartman Values Profile

Study (Author, Year)	Focus	Sample	Key Findings Relevant to Clinical Psychology
Smith & Harvey 40	Criterion Validity	Managerial candidates	Demonstrated a 90% successful rate for managerial candidates with low risk as determined by the HVP, suggesting its potential to predict successful adaptation and performance in demanding roles.
Biderman et al. 40	Concurrent Validity	Undergraduate students	Found a positive correlation between HVP scores and undergraduate student performance, indicating a relationship between valuing patterns and academic success, which could relate to motivation and learning styles in a clinical context.
University of South Florida 28	Criterion Validity, Application (Healthcare)	Over 600 surgical residency candidates and faculty physicians	Demonstrated a correlation between specific HVP scoring areas and most successful performers in surgical residencies, highlighting its potential to identify individuals with strong problem-solving ability, creativity, adaptability, and resilience under stress, qualities highly relevant to navigating personal and psychological challenges.
Kinsel Enterprises, Inc. 13	Criterion Validity (Sales, Management)	Various groups in sales and management roles	Proved the HVP to be valid in determining customer service and management characteristics necessary for success, suggesting its utility in understanding work-related values and potential areas of conflict or satisfaction that might be explored in therapy.
Value, Inc. 13	Criterion Validity (Sales)	Sales professionals	Demonstrated sales criterion validity, indicating the HVP's ability to predict success in sales roles, which could be relevant for clients exploring career changes or experiencing work-related distress due to value mismatches.
Kinsel Enterprises, Inc. 13	Predictive Validity	Not specified	Proved predictive validity to a confidence greater than 99.5%, suggesting the HVP's strong ability to forecast future outcomes based on an individual's valuing patterns, which could be valuable in understanding long-term trajectories related to mental health and well-being.
Brief Encounters Organization 37	Application (Healthcare), Impact on Outcomes	Healthcare organization using HVP in hiring process	Reported higher performance, increased quality of patient care, and reduced turnover/vacancy rates after implementing the HVP in their hiring process, suggesting that aligning organizational values with individual values can lead to positive outcomes, a principle that could be applied to understanding client satisfaction and progress in therapy.
Research described in 40 & 39	Validity, Reliability, Application (Healthcare)	Resident selection programs (anecdotal evidence from small samples)	Initial experiences suggest that incorporating the HVP into residency selection may add objectivity and refinement in predicting resident performance, with anecdotal evidence of zero attrition and a decline in faculty/resident complaints, indicating its potential to identify individuals better suited for demanding and stressful environments, which could be relevant to understanding resilience in clients.

VI. Limitations and Considerations

While the Hartman Values Profile aims for objectivity through its grounding in Formal Axiology, it is important to acknowledge that all value assessments, including the HVP, can be subject to certain biases.17 The interpretation of the HVP results, even with standardized reports, can still be influenced by the therapist's own personal values and inherent biases. For instance, a therapist who highly values autonomy might interpret a client's strong emphasis on self-direction in a particular way, potentially overlooking other important aspects of their value profile. Furthermore, the HVP itself identifies potential biases in an individual's valuing style, such as an overemphasis or underemphasis on a particular dimension, and the recognition and discussion of these biases within the therapeutic context requires careful consideration and sensitivity on the part of the therapist.
Cultural considerations and the potential for cultural influences on individual value systems are also important factors to bear in mind when utilizing the Hartman Values Profile.24 While some sources suggest that the HVP is not biased by socio-cultural classifications and has demonstrated similar score distributions across different demographic groups 37, the complex and multifaceted nature of human values necessitates a cautious and culturally sensitive approach to interpretation. Values are often deeply embedded within cultural norms and beliefs, and while the fundamental structure of valuing might have universal aspects, the specific expression and prioritization of particular values can vary significantly across different cultures. Therefore, a therapist should always consider the client's cultural background and context when interpreting their HVP results to avoid imposing their own cultural value judgments or making potentially inaccurate assumptions. Further research on the HVP's cultural sensitivity and its applicability across diverse populations would be beneficial to enhance its utility in a multicultural clinical practice.
Effective and ethical implementation of the Hartman Values Profile in clinical practice requires proper training and a thorough understanding of its underlying theoretical framework.6 The HVP is not simply a "personality test" with straightforward interpretations; it is based on the complex principles of Formal Axiology, and its results offer nuanced insights into an individual's valuing patterns and judgment processes. Therefore, clinicians should seek out comprehensive training programs that cover the theoretical foundations of Formal Axiology, the specific scoring system of the HVP, the meaning of different profile patterns, and the potential clinical implications of these insights. Relying solely on the HVP report without adequate training could lead to superficial interpretations, misapplication of the findings, and potentially ineffective or even harmful therapeutic interventions. Many sources recommend consultation with certified axiologists or practitioners experienced in using the HVP to ensure accurate and responsible application in clinical settings.
It is also important to acknowledge certain criticisms and limitations associated with the Hartman Values Profile. Some sources mention a lack of widespread standardization compared to other more established psychometric assessments, and there may be a limited number of peer-reviewed studies specifically focused on its application and effectiveness within diverse clinical psychology populations.39 Clinicians should also be careful to differentiate the HVP, which is rooted in Formal Axiology, from other assessments that might bear the "Hartman" name but are based on different theoretical frameworks, such as the Color Code personality profile, which has faced criticism regarding its scientific validity.44 While the HVP shows considerable promise as a tool for enhancing clinical understanding, it is prudent to approach it with a critical and informed perspective, acknowledging the existing body of research while also recognizing areas where further empirical investigation is warranted, particularly within specific clinical populations and across diverse cultural contexts.

VII. The Hartman Values Profile Compared to Other Assessment Tools

The Hartman Values Profile offers a unique perspective on clients that distinguishes it from other commonly used assessment tools in clinical psychology.5 Unlike personality inventories such as the MMPI or the Big Five, which aim to describe relatively stable patterns of thoughts, feelings, and behaviors, the HVP specifically focuses on how individuals make value judgments and prioritize different aspects of their lives.5 While correlations between HVP scores and personality traits have been observed, they remain distinct constructs.10 Compared to interest inventories like the Strong Interest Inventory, which identify preferences for certain activities and occupations, the HVP delves deeper by revealing the underlying values that drive these interests.37 The HVP is not a measure of intellectual capacity like cognitive ability tests such as the WAIS; instead, it assesses an individual's "good judgment" and how they process information in relation to their values.10 While other values assessments exist, the HVP stands out due to its grounding in Formal Axiology and its mathematically structured approach to understanding value hierarchies and judgment patterns.13 This theoretical foundation and analytical rigor differentiate the HVP, potentially offering a more objective and nuanced understanding of a client's internal value landscape compared to other value-based assessments.

Table 2: Comparison of the Hartman Values Profile with Other Assessment Tools

Assessment Tool	Primary Focus	Key Strengths	Unique Contributions Compared to HVP
Personality Inventories	Relatively stable personality traits	Comprehensive description of personality dimensions and patterns.	Focuses on values and judgment processes rather than personality traits.
Interest Inventories	Preferences for activities and occupations	Guidance for career exploration based on expressed interests.	Identifies underlying values that drive specific interests, offering a deeper level of understanding.
Cognitive Ability Tests	Intellectual capacities and cognitive skills	Measures reasoning, memory, problem-solving abilities, and overall intelligence.	Assesses "good judgment" and information processing related to values, distinct from general cognitive abilities.
Other Value Assessments	Identification of important personal values	Clarifies individual values and priorities.	Mathematically grounded in Formal Axiology, assesses clarity and attention in valuing, providing a structured analysis of the valuing process.

VIII. Case Studies in Clinical Practice

The Hartman Values Profile can be a valuable adjunct to various clinical presentations.

Example 1: Client experiencing anxiety and indecisiveness: An individual presenting with significant anxiety and difficulty making decisions might reveal through the HVP a strong need for systemic structure and order, coupled with a low score in practical judgment, indicating a fear of making mistakes in the real world. This insight can inform treatment by focusing on interventions that help the client build confidence in their decision-making abilities, develop strategies for tolerating uncertainty, and challenge rigid systemic expectations.
Example 2: Couple in conflict: In couples therapy, administering the HVP to both partners might reveal differing value priorities. For instance, one partner might score high in intrinsic valuing of relationships, prioritizing emotional connection and shared experiences, while the other partner scores higher in extrinsic valuing of achievement, emphasizing professional success and tangible accomplishments. Understanding these fundamental differences can help the therapist facilitate discussions around these core values, fostering empathy and guiding the couple towards finding compromises that respect both individuals' priorities.
Example 3: Client struggling with low self-esteem: A client presenting with persistent low self-esteem might exhibit low intrinsic valuing of self on the HVP, along with a tendency towards high self-criticism. These results can guide therapeutic interventions aimed at fostering self-acceptance and self-compassion. The therapist might also explore the client's systemic values, such as their internal standards and expectations, to identify and challenge any unrealistic or overly critical self-assessments that contribute to their low self-esteem.

These examples illustrate how the HVP can provide specific and actionable insights that can directly inform the process of clinical assessment and treatment planning.11

IX. Conclusion and Recommendations

Integrating the Hartman Values Profile into clinical psychology practice offers several potential benefits. It provides a unique and scientifically grounded perspective on a client's core values and their underlying judgment processes. The HVP can offer valuable insights into a client's motivations, their characteristic decision-making patterns, and potential sources of their psychological distress. Furthermore, it has the capacity to enhance a client's self-awareness, improve the therapeutic rapport between client and therapist, and inform the development of tailored and value-congruent treatment plans.

For clinical psychologists considering incorporating the HVP into their practice, the following recommendations are offered:

Obtain proper training: Given the theoretical complexity of Formal Axiology and the nuanced nature of HVP interpretation, it is crucial to seek comprehensive training in its administration and application.
Use as a supplementary tool: The HVP should be viewed as a valuable adjunct to, rather than a replacement for, a comprehensive clinical assessment approach that includes interviews, behavioral observations, and other relevant psychological measures.
Consider cultural context: Always interpret HVP results with sensitivity to the client's cultural background and be mindful of potential cultural influences on the expression and prioritization of values.
Focus on client growth: Utilize the insights gained from the HVP to facilitate a deeper understanding within the client, empowering them to make more conscious choices aligned with their core values and fostering personal growth.

By adhering to these recommendations, clinical psychologists can ethically and effectively leverage the potential of the Hartman Values Profile to enrich their clinical understanding of their clients and ultimately enhance therapeutic outcomes.

Works cited

VALIDITY STUDIES OF THE HARTMAN VALUE PROFILE MODEL - Axiologic, accessed April 2, 2025, https://www.axiologic.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/HartmanValidityStudies.pdf
Robert S. Hartman - Wikipedia, accessed April 2, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_S._Hartman
Science of value - Wikipedia, accessed April 2, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science_of_value
Getting 40% more commitment and productivity from your team - Project Management Institute, accessed April 2, 2025, https://www.pmi.org/learning/library/getting-forty-productivity-intrinsic-validation-7030
The Hartman Value Profile Retention Tool - Prime Care Technologies, accessed April 2, 2025, https://www.primecaretech.com/news/the-hartman-value-profile-retention-tool-not-just-another-personality-test
Hartman Value Profile (HVP) - Your Performance People, accessed April 2, 2025, https://yourperformancepeople.com/hiring-and-development-tools/hartman-value-profile/
Hartman Value Profile White Paper - Ruhmann Associates, accessed April 2, 2025, https://www.ruhmannassociates.com/web/articles/21
What is Axiology in Assessments? - TTI Success Insights Blog, accessed April 2, 2025, https://blog.ttisi.com/what-is-axiology-in-assessments
Defining "Formal Axiology" - Robert S. Hartman Institute, accessed April 2, 2025, https://www.hartmaninstitute.org/index.php?option=com_dailyplanetblog&view=entry&category=research&id=37:defining-formal-axiology
The Hartman Value Profile, accessed April 2, 2025, https://www.valuepartnersconsulting.com/about-us/the-hartman-value-profile
The Hartman Value Profile, accessed April 2, 2025, https://valuepartnersconsulting.com/about-us/the-hartman-value-profile
Hartman Value Profile | Buy DISC Personality Profiles - 24x7 Assessments, accessed April 2, 2025, https://24x7assessments.com.au/hartman-value-profile/
Hartman-Kinsel Profile - Clear Direction : Self-Understanding Made Simple, accessed April 2, 2025, https://www.cleardirection.com/docs/khp.asp
The Dimensions of Value - Insight Consulting, Inc., accessed April 2, 2025, https://valueinsights.com/the-dimensions-of-value/
Explaining Intuitive Agility With The Hartman Value Profile, accessed April 2, 2025, https://www.hartmaninstitute.org/index.php?option=com_dailyplanetblog&view=entry&category=research&id=23:explaining-intuitive-agility-with-the-hartman-value-profile
Hartman Value Profile Correct Answers - America First Legal, accessed April 2, 2025, https://ftp.aflegal.org/textbooks/scholarship/fetch.php/hartman_value_profile_correct_answers.pdf
Hartman Value Profile - Leadership - Authentika Consulting, accessed April 2, 2025, https://authentikaconsulting.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/HVP-Sample-Report.pdf
Hartman Value Profile, accessed April 2, 2025, http://dazley.com/Hartman.html
Hartman's Values - Peter Roemeling, accessed April 2, 2025, https://peterroemeling.nl/en/2021/01/hartmans-values.html
The Hartman Value Profile – Replace Your Surface-Level Personality Tests - James Mueller, accessed April 2, 2025, https://jmuellerassociates.com/hartman-value-profile/
Hartman Value Profile - Self - Assessments 24x7, accessed April 2, 2025, https://www.assessments24x7.com/reports/tsselfsample.pdf
Critical Thinking - Hartman Value Profile (HVP) Online Assessment, accessed April 2, 2025, https://ww3.blindspots.com/hartman-value-profile-assessment
hartman-icon Critical Thinking (HVP) - Assessments 24x7, accessed April 2, 2025, https://www.assessments24x7.com/assessments/critical-thinking-hvp
Hartman Value Profile - Leadskill, accessed April 2, 2025, https://leadskill.com/hartman-value-profile/
Advanced Insights Profile - DISC+Plus, accessed April 2, 2025, https://discplusprofiles.com/advanced-insights-profile/
Tool 8: Assessing Your Values, Decision Style, and Readiness for Change Using the HVP, accessed April 2, 2025, https://reflections.org/recalibrate/tool-8-assessing-your-values-decision-style-and-readiness-for-change-using-the-hartman-value-profile/
Hartman Value Profile - i-3 Coaching and Consulting, accessed April 2, 2025, https://sarasotacoach.com/hartman-value-profile/
Using the Hartman Value Profile in Residence Recruitment - PMC, accessed April 2, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4956881/
Hartman's Value Profile - YouTube, accessed April 2, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e8PqmH4OpCo
Hartman Value Profile – Self - HR Girlfriends, accessed April 2, 2025, https://hrgirlfriends.com/product/hartman-value-profile-self/
Tool 8, accessed April 2, 2025, https://reflections.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/DL-Tool-8-Expanded-Assessing-Using-the-HVP.pdf
The Hartman Value Profile - Insight Consulting, Inc., accessed April 2, 2025, https://valueinsights.com/axiology/the-hartman-value-profile/
Hartman Value Profile Correct Answers - America First Legal, accessed April 2, 2025, https://ftp.aflegal.org/textbooks/Resources/filedownload.ashx/Hartman_Value_Profile_Correct_Answers.pdf
The People Code. Unlocking Relationships with Dr. Taylor Hartman | Podcast, accessed April 2, 2025, https://www.invigormedical.com/podcasts/the-people-code-unlocking-relationships-with-dr-taylor-hartman/
Hartman Value Profile Self - Coaching and Tools, accessed April 2, 2025, https://coachingandtools.eu/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/Hartman-Value-Profile-self-sample.pdf
Blog Value Life Hack - XQ Research, accessed April 2, 2025, https://xqresearch.com/blog/
Hartman Value Profile | Brief Encounters, accessed April 2, 2025, https://www.brief-encounters.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/Hartman-Value-Profile.pdf
The Color Code: Dr. Hartman Personality Assessment Tool - Apex Social Group, accessed April 2, 2025, https://apex-social.com/color-code/
(PDF) A Novel Adjuvant to the Resident Selection Process: the Hartman Value Profile, accessed April 2, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/227712770_A_Novel_Adjuvant_to_the_Resident_Selection_Process_the_Hartman_Value_Profile
A Novel Adjuvant to the Resident Selection Process: the Hartman Value Profile - PMC, accessed April 2, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3375997/
The Hartman Value Profile - Wallach Business Solutions LLC, accessed April 2, 2025, https://www.wallachbusiness.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/hartman_validity_study.pdf
The Application of Formal Axiology to Medical Education through the Hartman Value Profile: A prospective cohort study - PMC, accessed April 2, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6820012/
Hartman Value Profile - HVP - Axiometric Partners, accessed April 2, 2025, https://www.axiometricspartners.com/axiology/hartman-value-profile-hvp
Hartman Personality Profile - Wikipedia, accessed April 2, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hartman_Personality_Profile
Hartman Value Profile - Kimberly Blankenship - Prezi, accessed April 2, 2025, https://prezi.com/qmgw6goqpgi6/hartman-value-profile/
accessed January 1, 1970, https://www.assessmentpsychology.com/test-critiques/hartman-value-inventory.htm
Personality Assessments - HR Girlfriends, accessed April 2, 2025, https://hrgirlfriends.com/personality-assessments/

The audio version

Laravel's robust library of first-party tools and libraries, such as Forge, Vapor, Nova, Envoyer, and Herd help you take your projects to the next level. Pair them with powerful open source libraries like Cashier, Dusk, Echo, Horizon, Sanctum, Telescope, and more.